• Advertise
  • Request Review
  • Write for Us
  • Privacy
  • Login

Theatre Bubble

The UK Theatre Network

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy
  • Reviews
  • News
  • Features
  • Spotlight
  • Opinions
  • Interviews
  • Guides

The Simon & Garfunkel Story at the Lyric Theatre

September 7, 2017 by Alex Wood Leave a Comment

Review of: The Simon & Garfunkel Story at the Lyric Theatre
Price:
From £18

Reviewed by: Alex Wood
Rating:
3
On September 7, 2017
Last modified:September 7, 2017

Summary:

A note-perfect performance of the classics is let down by an uninspiring show structure.

More Details

My love of Simon and Garfunkel operates on two levels. First and foremost they have a personal resonance, being a band that I turned to during stressful periods – long walks home singing Bridge Over Troubled Water to myself, a young man growing up on the rural outskirts of Birmingham, quickly spring to mind. But secondly, the pair’s central relationship, a fractious and fraught one at that, was so compelling, so enthralling, that I digested hours of content. In a way the relationship was quite wondrous – two individuals, capable of creating so much exuberance and beauty in their music (to the extent that they filled Central Park in the 1980s for their free concert) having an intrinsic and sustained dislike for one another. You can see it in their (especially Art’s) body language – the pair just didn’t get on.

Of my two loves for the pair, the former was certainly satisfied by the Simon and Garfunkel Story, which has one-off performances at the Lyric Theatre on Shaftesbury Avenue every month until December. The two performers, Sam O’Hanlon and  Charles Blyth, capture the brilliance of the duo perfectly, inhabiting the roles rather than impersonating them. Blyth’s Garfunkel is particularly uncanny, while O’Hanlon manages to make Paul Simon’s accomplishments on the guitar look like a natural skillset. The realism hums through the theatre. Though it’s hard to pull out highlights, the buoyancy of their “Cecilia” especially stood out. The quiet melodies of “Kathy’s Song” were also enchantingly understated.

But it was on the latter of my two loves that the show seemed to fall down. While billed as the “story” of Simon and Garfunkel, the show fundamentally felt like a chronological cycle through the hits, jumping from album to album with whimsical breeze. It was less of a story and more of a run-through of the greatest hits. A shift in structure would have benefited the pair perfectly – rather than relying on chronology, place the pair’s temperamental relationship at the heart of the show and let that be the driver for the performance – this was where the greatest fruit grew. The punch of the Boxer would have been more keenly felt, while the release of Bridge Over Troubled Water would have been a refreshing relief for the audience at the end of the act. The emotion felt, fundamentally, lost by the end.

So every kudos must go to the beautiful performances involved, and the show could be quite readily rectified, but this was a performance with an intrinsic problem – it took two of the most emotional performers of the last 50 years and sapped them of some of the magic. A tribute to the music, but not, unfortunately, to the musicians.

Author: Alex WoodAlex is the former reviews editor at Theatre Bubble, but since changing position now contributes occasionally. He has been writing reviews for a number of years, as well as seeing his own shows performed. He has produced and marketed a number of performances at venues in London, Oxford, Edinburgh, including the world premiere of Philip Pullman's The Ruby in the Smoke.

Filed Under: Review

Join the discussion Cancel reply

INTERVIEW / Kati Raatikainen on Kvartetto

We spoke to choreographer Kati Raatikainen about her upcoming performance of Kvartetto at the Edinburgh Fringe as part of the [Read More]

INTERVIEW / Harry Butler on Changing the Sheets

We spoke to writer and performer Harry Butler about his upcoming performance of Changing the Sheets, presented by The Playground [Read More]

INTERVIEW / Jamaal Burkmar on DONUTS

We spoke to choreographer Jaamal Burkmar about Extended Play’s upcoming performance of DONUTS at the Edinburgh Fringe, presented by The [Read More]

INTERVIEW / Heather Milsted tells us about her show Period Dramas

We spoke to actor and writer Heather Milsted about her upcoming show, Period Dramas, that’s heading to the Edinburgh Fringe [Read More]

INTERVIEW / Helen Banner on her play Intelligence

We spoke to playwright Helen Banner about the upcoming performance of her play Intelligence with Dutch Kills Theater Company which [Read More]

Top Posts & Pages

  • 10 Tips to Help You Prepare for Your Reality TV Auditions
  • 5 Stage Elements to Consider for a Rousing Theatrical Production
  • Katy Owen: LAMDA Audition (First Round)
  • The Threepenny Opera at the National Theatre
  • Joe Strickland on why they will be keeping things digital
  • A Streetcar Named Desire- A cry of pain- Young Vic
  • Does Small to Mid Scale Theatre Touring Actually Work?
  • Katy Owen: Auditioning for Oxford School of Drama
  • Sarah Bodalbhai on Escape from Planet Trash
  • Writing the Perfect Press Release
  • Alex Wood
    Contributor

  • September 7th, 2017
  • comment iconNo Comments
  • Facebook1TweetLinkedInEmail

    Newsletter

    Enjoyed what you've read? Get even more great content directly to your inbox - Completely Free

    About Theatre Bubble

    Theatre Bubble is the news, review and blogging site created by Blue Pie Media and run by a dedicated team of outstanding editors and writers: we're always looking for new contributors - to find out more click here.

    Contact Us

    News: news@theatrebubble.com
    Reviews: reviews@theatrebubble.com
    Website: webmaster@theatrebubble.com

    Privacy Policy

    Copyright © 2022 · Blue Pie Media

     

    Loading Comments...
     

      Share this ArticleLike this article? Email it to a friend!

      Email sent!